Once you have decided to start a business you need to decide what type of legal entity to use. An important element in your consideration will be the tax consequences of each type of entity. We discuss the various types of entities and tax implications thereon below.
1. Sole Proprietorship
The simplest form, a sole proprietorship is a business that is owned by one person. The business has no existence apart from the owner (the proprietor). Only the proprietor has decision making authority, and assumes the risks of the business to the extent of all his or her assets whether used in the business or personally owned.
Advantages:
| The business is simple to organise | |
| The owner is free to make decisions | |
| The business has few legal requirements | |
| The owner receives all the profits | |
| The business is easy to discontinue |
Disadvantages:
| Unlimited liability for the owner - the owner is legally liable for all debts of the business, so any personal and real property may be attached by creditors | |
| Limited ability to raise capital - which in turn limits the expansion of a business when new capital is needed | |
| Limited skills - although the owner can hire employees with other skills |
2.
Partnerships
A partnership is the relationship between two or more people who join together in business. Each person contributes money, property, labour or skills, and in turn each shares the profits and losses of the business. The number of people who may join a partnership is limited to twenty.
Advantages:
| It is easy to organise | |
| It has greater financial strength | |
| Managerial skills of the partners are combined | |
| It has a definite legal status | |
| Each partner has a personal interest in the business |
Disadvantages:
| Unlimited liability of the partners - therefore one partner can cause the loss of assets of the partnership as well as the personal assets of the remaining partners | |
| The authority for decisions is divided |
3.
Close Corporation
A close corporation is a legal entity with its own legal personality and perpetual succession. The owners are the members, who do not hold shares but have an interest in the cc, which is expressed as a percentage. The maximum number of members is ten.
Advantages:
| It is simple to organise | |
| The life of the business is perpetual (i.e. continues after members die) | |
| The members have limited liability | |
| The transfer of ownership is easy | |
| Fewer legal requirements than a private company |
Disadvantages:
| It is subject to special taxation rates | |
| The maximum number of members is restricted to ten | |
| More legal requirements than a sole proprietorship or partnership |
4.
Private Company
A company is treated by law as a single legal entity, separate from its owners with rights and duties of its own. The owners are shareholders, and the managers may or may not be shareholders. The maximum number of shareholders is limited to fifty.
Advantages:
| The life of the business is perpetual | |
| The shareholders have limited liability | |
| The transfer of ownership is easy | |
| It is easier to raise capital and expand | |
| Efficiency of management is maintained | |
| It is adaptable to both small and large business |
Disadvantages:
| Is it subject to special taxation rates | |
| It is more difficult and expensive to organise than other forms of ownership | |
| It is subject to many legal requirements |
Summary
of Advantages and Disadvantages of the four types of business organisations:
ADVANTAGES:
|
SOLE
PROPRIETORSHIP
|
PARTNERSHIP
|
CLOSE
CORPORATION
|
PRIVATE
COMPANY
|
|
| 1. | Simple to organise | Simple to organise | Simple to organise | Perpertual life |
| 2. | Owner free to make decisions | Greater financial strength | Perpetual life | Limited to transfer ownership |
| 3. | Minimum legal requirements, skills, etc. | Combined managerial skills | Limited liability | Easy to transfer ownership |
| 4. | Owner receives all profits | Definite legal status | Easy to transfer ownership | Maintenance of management |
| 5. | Easy to discontinue | Partners have personal interest | Fewel legal requirements than a private company | Adaptable to small and large businesses |
DISADVANTAGES:
|
SOLE
PROPRIETORSHIP
|
PARTNERSHIP
|
CLOSE
CORPORATION
|
PRIVATE
COMPANY
|
|
| 1. | Unlimited liability of owner | Unlimited liability of partners | Special taxation rates | Special taxation rates |
| 2. | Limited ability to raise capital | Authority for decisions divided | Maximum of ten members | More difficult and expensive to organise |
| 3. | Limited skills | More legal requirements than sole proprietorship or partnership | Subject to many legal requirements |
Comparative tax structures of each of the four forms of business organisation
In order to understand the tax consequences of each of the four business organisations, you need to understand the basic steps for determining your business' profit or loss (see the article, Record Keeping).
Registering with the appropriate authorities
Before you actually start your business, you may need to register with certain authorities in order to comply with the laws or regulations pertaining to your area of operation. It will be in your own interest to make enquiries in this regard and to comply with all the requirements that might be set. Some of the requirements that might apply to you are mentioned below, however the list is not comprehensive and it is advisable for you to consult a lawyer.
Receiver
of Revenue - you may have to register for one or more of the following:
| Income Tax: as soon as you start business, you need to register with your local Receiver of Revenue in order to obtain an income tax reference number. | |
| Employees Tax (PAYE): a system of Employees Tax collection is in force in South Africa. You need to therefore deduct tax from your employees' salaries or wages and pay this over to your local Receiver of Revenue. | |
| Value-Added Tax (VAT): VAT is a tax that must be included in the price of every taxable supply. When your taxable supplies exceed or are likely to exceed R150 000 per annum, you are obliged to register for VAT at your local Receiver of Revenue. | |
| Unemployment Insurance Fund (U.I.F.): this fund provides for the insurance of employees against the risk of loss of earnings arising from unemployment. An employee is required within 14 days of starting to submit to the Unemployment Insurance Fund a notification form U.I.F. which can be obtained from the fund on application. This fund is administered by the Department of Manpower, and all correspondence must be addressed accordingly. | |
| Regional Services Council (R.S.C.): these are statutory autonomous bodies, similar to local authorities, and have been established to render services on a regional basis. Any person within the region who employs people or owns a business must register with the R.S.C. Enquiries in this regard must be directed to your local regional authority. | |
| Other authorities who you may need to register with are: | |
|
Information supplied by the South African Revenue Services, compiled by Bizland
Back
to www.bizland.co.za